miaa MI
@miaa
GTA & Open World Oct 23, 2026

Was Arthur Morgan actually a good man? (RDR2 spoilers)

Just finished the story and I can't decide. He does a lot of terrible things early on but the ending really pushes the redemption angle. Do you think he earned it, or does the game go too easy on him?
arthur morgan good
1

Leave A Reply

Log in to post an answer.

1 Answer

K
kiran_plays Oct 27, 2026
miaa
a good man by the end, which isn't the same as a good man. he spent most of his life robbing and killing for dutch and he knew it. what makes him interesting is that once he's dying he stops lying to himself about it and starts trying to do one decent thing with the time he's got, mostly for john and abigail. the honour system makes it your call too. high honour arthur and low honour arthur feel like two different people in the last chapter.
Reply